Skip to content
A blue stacked chart graph
Back to Research

May 31, 2022

Smooth Consumers - Flexport Weekly Economic Report

Smooth Consumers - Flexport Weekly Economic Report

phil levy headshot
Phil Levy

Chief Economist, Flexport

May 31, 2022

The pandemic era has seen wild swings in US personal savings, with the rate hitting its lowest in over a decade in April. The accumulated savings during the pandemic have allowed consumption to remain strong, even as income growth has faltered. Most recently, there has been a split between stronger durables and weaker non-durables consumption.

In Focus - Transfers, For The Save

markdown image

It is hardly daring to say that economic behavior under the pandemic has been unusual. The challenge has been to quantify and, if possible, explain. The dark line in the chart shows the U.S. personal savings rate and uses the scale on the right (percentage). In the 20 years leading up to February 2020, the median monthly value was 6.2% and the rate ranged between 2.1% (in mid-2005) and 11.6% (end 2012). Mostly, changes were gradual and unexciting, as they appear in the beginning of this chart.

In the pandemic, the median monthly savings rate was 12.8%, with a high of 33.8% (April 2020) and a low of 4.4% – just announced for April 2022. That new figure is the lowest since September 2008, when the Global Financial Crisis hit.

This is not just of academic interest. If we want to understand how much consumers will spend on goods, we can break the question down into three parts:

  • How much money do they have?
  • How much of it do they save?
  • Of the part they spend, how much will be on goods (vs. services).

The Bureau of Economic Analysis this week just put out new data for April that sheds light on each part of this sequence. We can start with the savings behavior we described above. The chart shows a bizarre, if suggestive, correlation.

Oddly enough, it’s between a percentage rate (right scale, navy line) and the real level of “government social benefits to persons” (left scale, $2012 trillions). The more money the US government pushed at consumers, the more they saved. This makes some sense from an economic standpoint – people try to “smooth” consumption, rather than going from feast to famine.

Economists usually apply this concept across a lifetime, so people spend more than they earn while students or retirees, and less than they earn during their prime working years. It was a substantially trickier proposition during the pandemic, when there was no certainty about how long the unusual stretch would last.

The buildup of savings meant there could be a month like April, when real disposable personal (DPI) income stayed flat, but real personal consumption expenditures (PCE) rose 0.7%. Looking back over the last six months, real DPI fell by 1.8% while real PCE rose by 1.2%. At some point, either incomes will pick up or consumption will slow.

The real consumption increase over the last six months was a balance between rising consumption of services and falling consumption of goods. April marked a break in the recent trend. From March to April, real durable goods consumption was up 2.3%, while services consumption was up 0.5% and non-durables consumption was up 0.2%.

If you find that pattern unsurprising – that durables consumption remained strong relative to services while non-durables consumption faded in relative terms – it’s probably because you read our Post-Covid Indicator forecast from May 16.

Latest Flexport Metrics & Research

The Flexport Ocean Timeliness Indicator for Transpacific Eastbound routes fell by two days to 100 days, the lowest since last November. Flexport’s Air Timeliness Indicator meanwhile fell to its lowest since June 27, 2021 in the four weeks to May 29 at 11.1 days average.

In other research we published two reports on conditions and strategies in the apparel sector. We’ve also taken a look at four strategies for dealing with the weak U.K. consumer economy.

Economics Data

Along with income and consumption information, the Bureau of Economic Analyses released a key inflation gauge. The PCE Deflator showed annual inflation at a 6.3% rate in April, down from 6.6% reported in March.

  • Broken down, that was a 9.5% annual inflation rate for goods (also down from March) but a 4.6% rate for services (up). The “Trimmed Mean PCE Deflator” that is closely watched by the Fed rose to 3.8%, its highest level since 1991.

Real U.S. Q1 GDP shrank slightly faster than first thought, decreasing at a 1.5% annual rate, vs. the initial 1.4% estimate. Contributing factors to the revision were slower inventory buildup (e.g. autos), slower exports, and faster imports.

U.S. international merchandise trade activity fell by 8.3% sequentially in April. A drop in commodity prices dragged industrial imports and exports down by 14.2% and 11.1% respectively. A 12.2% slide in consumer goods imports may reflect a wider slowdown, though on a year over year basis imports were still up by 14.3%.

The value of U.S. retail inventories fell by 0.7% in April compared to March. That marked the first decline since September 2021 and came as sales rose by 0.9%. While automotive inventories improved, retail store and non-store (e-commerce) inventories dropped by 1.6%.

  • Wholesale inventories meanwhile increased by 2.1% sequentially, led by a 2.3% rise in nondurable goods.

U.S. new home sales dropped 16.6% from March to April and were down 26.9% from April of 2021. This coincided with rising mortgage rates and, along with existing home sales, can presage a slowdown in purchases of home furnishings.

The University of Michigan consumer sentiment final reading for May hit its lowest level in over 10 years.

  • The U.S. Federal Reserve released a household survey which showed self-reported economic well-being in 2021 at its highest level since the survey started in 2013.

Purchasing managers’ sentiment in China rebounded in May with the official CFLP survey recovering to 49.6 from 47.4 in April, suggesting improving business conditions following factory closures. From a trade perspective both export and import expectations increased though both were still below March’s levels.

  • Business conditions in Germany remained in negative territory in May according to the latest IFO survey. Overall business expectations remained close to their worst since the start of the pandemic. Export expectations improved slightly and imply expanding orders, but still at their lowest levels since the end of 2020.

The World Trade Organization’s measure of global exports of intermediate goods - a measure of supply chain activity rather than final consumption - grew by 21.5% year over year in Q4’21 and by 32.2% compared to Q4’19. Trade in electronic components led the way while the automotive sector lagged.

Politics & Regulations

The head of the European Central Bank announced plans to raise interest rates later in the year. While the U.S. Fed has had negative real interest rates (nominal rates lower than inflation), the ECB currently has negative nominal rates. The plan is to end those by the end of Q3, which will still leave the Euro Area with highly negative real rates.

  • The Euro area flash consumer price inflation rate reached 8.1% in May 2022 versus a year earlier. That was predominantly due to higher energy costs, though the rate ex energy still reached 4.1% in May versus 3.4% in March.

The Biden administration has begun discussions with partner countries for implementing its Indo-Pacific Economic Framework. The IPEF will focus on a series of “small-wins” in four major areas of trade rather than being an overarching deal. Not all countries will take part in all elements though commitments will be legally binding.

  • China meanwhile is expanding its Global Security Initiative to provide a counterweight to U.S. attempts to rebuild a coalition of partners in Asia and beyond.

The U.S. is also still in the process of reviewing its Section 301 tariffs on imports from China, with President Biden stating “they were imposed by the last administration, and they’re under consideration.” The tariffs have to be formally reviewed before July.

  • In a speech on the administration’s broader approach to China, Secretary of State Blinken struck an ambivalent tone, stressing competition but questioning disengagement by stating that “put simply, the United States and China have to deal with each other for the foreseeable future.”

The U.K. is continuing to expand its range of trade deal negotiations in the wake of Brexit. Talks with Mexico have started this week while a series of limited areas of cooperation with U.S. states has started with Indiana. That follows a return in jurisdiction over new deals to Parliament from Number 10.

Supply Chain Update

The European Commission has outlined contingency plans in the event that all Russian gas supplies become unavailable. That would include maximizing storage ahead of the winter but may also require rationing. So far the EU has launched sanctions against Russian coal and oil but not natural gas.

The Russian government has reportedly offered to reopen shipping lanes for food exports. That comes with the condition, however, that sanctions against the country are removed. The U.S. government appears unwilling to accede to the plan.

Elevated food prices have led to a round of protectionism export restrictions. India has already limited wheat exports and is also considering similar actions for sugar. The country is also cutting import duties in order to reduce food price inflation.

  • The Indian government is also carrying out similar actions for manufacturing with a mixture of export levies on steel while also reducing import tariffs on raw materials.

Chart of the Week - Running Low on Fuel

markdown image

Rising diesel prices, in part due to elevated oil prices linked to the Ukraine conflict, have driven inflation across supply chains due to higher costs for trucking. Diesel fuel prices in the U.S. remain close to their highest since the EIA started collecting data in 1996 as shown in the chart above.

There’s also an emerging shortage of diesel in the U.S. While somewhat seasonal, U.S. stocks of distillate fuel oil reached their lowest since May 2003 in the week to May 6, 2022 and remain close to that level. That has led the Biden administration to consider a release from emergency fuel reserves, on top of reported plans to restrict exports of crude oil.

There are already signs of a knock-on effect for the trucking industry. A survey of truckers indicates that high fuel prices are pushing participants out of the market while the American Trucking Association reported a 2% fall in truck tonnage in April.

Disclaimer: The contents of this report are made available for informational purposes only and should not be relied upon for any legal, business, or financial decisions. Flexport does not guarantee, represent, or warrant any of the contents of this report because they are based on our current beliefs, expectations, and assumptions, about which there can be no assurance due to various anticipated and unanticipated events that may occur. This report has been prepared to the best of our knowledge and research; however, the information presented herein may not reflect the most current regulatory or industry developments. Neither Flexport nor its advisors or affiliates shall be liable for any losses that arise in any way due to the reliance on the contents contained in this report.

About the Author

phil levy headshot
Phil Levy

Chief Economist, Flexport

May 31, 2022

Ready to Get Started?

Flexport makes shipping your cargo transparent, reliable, and affordable

Research Icon v3

Sign up for the Weekly Economic Report

Get the latest insights, trends and expert analysis on global trade and the economy.

About this author